The Vaccination Myth

Sex With Recent Smallpox Vaccine Recipient Can Lead to Illness

CDC reports case of woman who contracted vaccinia virus, main ingredient in the shot

By Steven Reinberg
HealthDay Reporter

Lifestyle

• Tyler Brûlé, Media Maverick
• Fiat Has a Lot Riding on A New Jeep Cherokee
• A Delightful Provençal Red
• Apple to Change IPhone Signal Display, Not Reception
• SEC Said to Review Principal-Protected Note Sales

Story Tools

• e-mail this story
• print this story
• order a reprint

THURSDAY, July 1 (HealthDay News) — After having sex with a soldier recently vaccinated against smallpox, a young woman in Washington state developed an illness caused by the vaccinia virus used in the shot, U.S. health officials report.

This type of viral transmission, while rare, is not unheard of, according to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

“The patient visited an urgent care clinic with painful, ring-shaped vaginal swelling,” explained Andrea McCollum, an Epidemic Intelligence Service Officer with the CDC. “A few days before that, she had sexual contact with her boyfriend who was a recent smallpox vaccinee via the military.”

Although smallpox is now almost eradicated, U.S. military personnel have been vaccinated in recent years as a precaution against the potential use of the virus in a biological attack. The smallpox vaccine comes in the form of a live vaccine, so there is always some risk of infection, McCollum said. “The vaccine is not smallpox virus,” she stressed, “but it’s a closely related virus called vaccinia.”

Although the woman told her doctor about her possible exposure to smallpox vaccine via sexual contact with her recently vaccinated boyfriend, the doctor tested her for common STDs but did not test for vaccinia, according to the report published in the July 1 issue of the CDC journal Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report.

Despite taking the antibiotics and antiviral medications that the doctor had prescribed, the woman continued having lesions and pain for the next three days, McCollum said.

A second doctor then sent her to an infectious disease specialist who confirmed that she had the vaccinia virus.

Vaccinia is relatively mild compared to smallpox, and the woman did not need any specific treatment. She did suffer some pain, soreness and irritation, which eventually resolved, McCollum said.

However, “we were quite concerned that she might transmit it to her household contacts,” McCollum said, because one of her roommates had had a kidney transplant. The transplant patient was immunosuppressed and taking a lot of medication. “A vaccinia virus infection, particularly in an immunosuppressed individual, can be very serious and life-threatening,” McCollum noted.

McCollum noted that there have been other cases of this infection transmitted from smallpox-vaccinated individuals to others. “At CDC, we don’t know about every case of vaccinia that occurs,” she said.

Including this case, the CDC is aware of five similar cases occurring over the past year, she said. “All the cases were women presenting with genital lesions that had had recent sexual contact exposure to military vaccinees.”

In addition to military personnel, others who are vaccinated include some health care workers and laboratory personnel who work with the virus, McCollum said.

In terms of immunizations generally, McCollum said the danger of transmitting a virus via a recent vaccination is present with vaccines that contain what’s known as live virus. Most vaccines — including most childhood and flu vaccines — are made from the killed virus, and therefore pose no such danger, she said.

Infectious disease expert Dr. Marc Siegel, an associate professor of medicine at New York University in New York City, said that “smallpox vaccine being a live virus, there is a two-to-three-week period when you are still infectious from the vaccination site and you have to be very careful to cover it.”

The oral polio vaccine is another live-attenuated vaccine, which has in very rare instances been associated with causing polio, Siegel noted.

However, the vast majority of vaccines utilize killed virus so this is not a problem with them, he reiterated. “One exception is the inhaled flu vaccine. You could transmit influenza in a very weakened form to an immunocompromised person,” he said. “But vaccinia is more infectious than that.”

“This is a reminder that live virus vaccines, which are increasingly in disuse, carry their own risk of minor infection and should not be used in immunocompromised people,” Siegel said.

Live virus vaccines do have one advantage, in that they create a stronger immune response than do killed virus vaccines, Siegel added.

More information

For more information on smallpox, visit the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

SOURCES: Andrea McCollum, Ph.D., Epidemic Intelligence Service officer, U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention; Marc Siegel, M.D., associate professor, medicine, New York University, New York City; July 1, 2010, Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report

Copyright © 2010 HealthDay. All rights reserved.

“Virus Shedding” is one of the safety concerns for live virus vaccines, such as Smallpox. The side-effects, then, are not necessarily only limited to the vaccine recipient.

How can “they” consider to make the flu vaccine mandatory, when by their own standards, it’s clear that safety testing has never been done?

I think it is becoming clearer by the day that there are no longer any fundamental human rights in North America.

3 good tips from a parent on how to speak to an autistic child:

don’t make these 3 mistakes:

1. speaking too fast – slow down and ennunciate
2. using sentences which are too long – keep in the range of your child’s sentence length
3. Using words unknown to the child

When considering vaccination, the issue of “virus shedding” from live vaccines, such as Pertussis, is one of the questions that comes up under the general issue of ‘vaccine safety’.